Pin It

Join almost 1/2 million
monthly
readers!

Contact Me

Coaching and Consultation

Current mission

Secret project in
Berlin! Subscribe to
email list to find out
about it first!

Previous post:

Next post:

How to Learn 2,000 Kanji in 3 Months: Mission Possible

| 62 comments | Category: guest post, particular languages

Today’s guest post is from John Fotheringham, who blogs at Foreign Language Mastery. I like his take on Language Hacking, so I was happy to share this post he wrote for us! Off you go, John!

Your mission, if you choose to accept it Mr. Hunt, is to master the meaning and writing of 2,042 “Standard Use Kanji” (常用漢字・じょうようかんじ) in 90 days. This feat normally takes the Japanese themselves all the way through the end of junior high school, and most non-native learners of Japanese never make it even after years of study.

But worry not! Armed with the right psychology and tools, this seemingly impossible mission becomes a walk in the park.

Mission Mental

The world’s best methods and materials amount to jack freaking squat unless you are fired up to use them day in and day out. So before we get to the cool tools you will use to complete your mission, let’s first focus first on the internal.

To succeed in your mission, you are going to apply the holy trinity of motivation:

  • Social Accountability
  • S.M.A.R.T. Goals
  • Baby Steps

Share Your Progress Publicly

Homo sapiens are an interesting animal. We rarely do things that we know are good for us (or avoid doing things we know are bad for us) unless we know that other people are watching. While one can argue that a mature, emotionally centered person shouldn’t care too much about what others think, the fact remains that almost all of us do.

Fortunately, the kanji learner can use this psychological phenomenon to their advantage:

  • Create a Kanji Learning Blog: Contrary to popular belief, blogs are not only outlets for self-obsessed narcissists. They are also an extremely effective way to share goals publicly (triggering our innate psychological programming to succeed in the eyes of others), develop a following (that we will feel obligated not to let down), and provide an outlet for sharing successes and failures during our mission (a cathartic, and very necessary aspect of language learning). There are countless blogging platforms to choose from, but don’t get caught up in the nitty gritty details. Just select one you feel comfortable with and get started now. [Benny: You can also start a log on the Fi3M forums, which lots of people interact with] And don’t worry too much about how your blog looks; the goal is to create accountability, share your triumphs and tribulations, and develop a following (however small); not to show how many hours or dollars you spent tweaking your theme.
  • Make Bets with a Friend or Colleague: The most potent form of social accountability involves betting. You can use financial incentives (good) or punishments (better) to boost commitment to your goals. For money based bets, agree on an amount that you can both pay but that will be somewhat painful. Likewise, punishments should involve something sufficiently detestable but not so outrageous that you both know from the get go that neither party will be actually be forced to follow through when the other wins. No matter the wager, make sure your competition centers around a specific goal tied to a specific timeframe, which leads us to the next key for success: goal creation.

Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Realistic, and Time Bound Goals

Most goals are doomed to failure from the beginning. In a moment of seasonal, alcohol-induced inspiration, we make exciting goals that are too large, too far away, and not clearly defined. It’s no wonder that nearly all New Year’s resolutions never become reality.

Luckily, S.M.A.R.T. (Specific, Measurable, Attainable, Realistic, and Time Bound) goals come to the rescue. You have likely heard this acronym before, and may brush it aside as nothing but fluffy motivational gibberish. That would be a mistake. If you’ve actually gone through the exercise of making such goals before, you know just how powerful they can be.

So what does a S.M.A.R.T. goal look like? You need look no further than the title of this post: “Learn 2,000 Kanji in 3 Months.”

  • It is Specific: Notice I didn’t say something like “Get good at kanji next year”. “Good” is not clearly defined as is therefore meaningless for our purposes.
  • It is Measurable: The goal includes a specific number so you know exactly how many kanji you have actually have learned by the deadline.
  • It is Attainable: If you are properly motivated and use the tools I suggest, there is no reason you shouldn’t succeed.
  • It is Realistic: Learning 2,000 kanji in one week is stretching it, but 3 months is a very doable timeframe if you are consistent.
  • It is Time Bound: You will be choosing a specific date on the calendar to complete your mission, not some vague “later this year” goal.

Now it’s your turn. Take out a piece of paper (writing by hand is better than typing; trust me!) and write down your own S.M.A.R.T. kanji goals. In addition to what you will do, also consider making goals about what you won’t do (i.e. quitting unhealthy, time consuming activities that get in the way of your learning goals like playing video games, watching T.V., sleeping too much, etc.)

If you are stuck, start with the following two goals:

  • How many kanji will I learn each day? Some simple math will show that you need to learn at least 23 kanji every day to complete your mission on schedule (2,042 kanji ÷ 90 days = 22.7). What I suggest is learning 25 to 30 a day to buy yourself some breathing room in case of unforeseen emergencies, business trips, social events, or Godzilla attacks. But no matter how many kanji you actually learn on a given day (even if the number is zero), keep track of it on your blog. If you fall below 25 kanji on a given day, you can always just make them up the next day. Just don’t let yourself get into that habit or you will quickly find yourself way behind schedule.
  • How many minutes / hours will I commit to learning each day? While not as crucial as the number of kanji you learn per day, your study time does matter. After you have gotten into the swing of things, you should have a good idea of how many minutes it takes you on average to learn one kanji. You can then figure out how many minutes per day you need to meet your daily kanji goal.

Take Baby Steps

If you ever catch yourself getting overwhelmed by the perceived immensity or distance of your final kanji goal (and we all do once in a while), just take a breath and remember to take things one kanji at a time. Or as Anne Lamott puts it in Bird by Bird, her must-read book on writing and life:

“Thirty years ago my older brother, who was ten years old at the time, was trying to get a report written on birds that he’d had three months to write, which was due the next day. We were out at our family cabin in Bolinas, and he was at the kitchen table close to tears, surrounded by binder paper and pencils and unopened books about birds, immobilized by the hugeness of the task ahead. Then my father sat down beside him put his arm around my brother’s shoulder, and said, “Bird by bird, buddy. Just take it bird by bird.”

Your Kanji Toolkit

Now that we have these essential psychological factors squared away, let’s cover the tools and technology you will use to accomplish your mission:

  • Remembering the Kanji (book and iOS app)
  • Anki (spaced repetition software for Mac, PC, Android and iOS)
  • WWWJDIC (web and app-based Japanese dictionary)

Remembering the Kanji (RTK)

There is a simple reason why it takes Japanese children a decade to learn all standard use kanji. The same reason accounts for the failure of most foreign adult learners to master Chinese characters. Rote memory.

Whether in a Japanese elementary school or a Japanese university class in the West, this same tired, ineffective method of learning is applied year after year despite its terrible track record. Fortunately, James Heisig’s breakthrough work Remembering the Kanji: A Complete Guide on How Not to Forget the Meaning and Writing of Japanese Characters provides us with a far more effective and adult friendly approach to learning kanji.

Instead of trying to force characters into memory through tedious repetition, Heisig’s approach leverages what he calls “imaginative memory”. Quite simply, the technique involves using your creativity and experience to create vivid, unforgettable stories that conjure up the basic meaning of a given kanji and the “primitive elements” of which it is composed. Or in Heisig’s words:

“The aim is to shock the mind’s eye, to disgust it, enchant it, to tease it, or to entertain it in any way possible so as to brand it with an image intimately associated with the key word.”

[Benny: I tried something similar myself with Thai symbols and explained how I learned to be able to read Thai in just a few hours here - so with a good imagination you can also attempt to create the associations yourself]

Here are some tips to get the most out of RTK:

  • Do not start going through the kanji until you have read the book’s introduction. The study method employed in RTK is very different from traditional study and it essential that you understand the “how” and “why” behind it.
  • Don’t just say the keywords out loud; literally see, hear, taste, smell and feel the stories.
  • Make sure you know the exact meaning of each and every keyword. Look them up on Wikipedia or do a Google Image search if necessary.
  • Study Before Bed and Upon Waking. Studying right before bed is a great way to unwind from your busy day. Moreover, our brains consolidate new information while we sleep so anything you get into your head before the lights go out has a better chance of being retained. Reviewing last night’s kanji upon waking ensures you get some study time in no matter how hectic your day becomes.
  • Use what Barry M. Farber, author of How to Learn Any Language, calls hidden moments, “those otherwise meaningless scraps of time you’d never normally think of putting to any practical use, and using them for language study—even if it’s no more than fifteen, ten, or five seconds at a time—can turn you into a triumphant tortoise.” [Benny: My thoughts on utilising your time better here, and how I do it with Anki explained below here]
  • Get the official RTK iOS app. It is not a replacement for the book (as it does not include the stories or instructions, but it does provide an excellent, portable way to review what you’ve already learned.

Anki

You may love flashcards or think they are the root of all evil. I personally find them a useful addition to (not replacement of) authentic content and communication with native speakers.

Anki (暗記・あんき), a name which literally means “memorization”, is a computer, web, and app based flashcard system that uses the powers of “spaced repetition” to help you better remember words, phrases, and yes, kanji. Like other spaced repetition systems (SRS), Anki automatically schedules re-exposures to specific cards based on how difficult you rate them. Easier cards will be shown less often while those more difficult will come back around right away. This makes your study time and energy far more efficient since you won’t have to waist your time going through items you already know.

Thankfully, other studious Anki users have already gone to the trouble of creating Remembering the Kanji flashcard decks. So all you have to do is download them onto your computer or mobile device and use your “hidden moments” for quick reviews throughout the day.

Just make sure that you have actually created strong, imaginative stories for each character first and don’t use Anki to fall back on the highly inefficient rote memorization track.

WWW JDIC

Jim Breen’s WWW JDIC is the de facto online Japanese dictionary for non-native speakers. You can look up kanji dozens of ways, including the character itself, the stroke count, the radical, the reading (in kana, romaji, or Chinese Pinyin), or the index code from any of the major kanji dictionaries.

You can access the dictionary free online or via the iOS app (Kotoba!) and Android app (WWWJDIC)

Use the dictionary any time you come across kanji in Remembering the Kanji that you are not 100% sure of the exact keyword meaning.

This Blog Post Will Self-Destruct in Five Seconds

  • 5… Set up your kanji blog
  • 4… Make bets with your friends
  • 3… Create your S.M.A.R.T. goals
  • 2… Get Remembering the Kanji
  • 1… Download Anki and the WWW JDIC apps.
  • Poof!

You now have everything you need to learn 2,042 kanji in 90 days. Good luck Mr. Hunt.

——————

From teaching to translating, John Fotheringham has been up and down the entire foreign language continuum (unfortunately, there is no frequent flyer program for language learning).
As both learner and teacher, he has spent the last decade testing first hand what works, and perhaps more importantly, what<em> doesn’t</em>. John shares these results on his blog and podcast <a title=”Foreign Language Mastery: Tips, Tools, and Tech to Learn Any Language Quickly, Cheaply, and On Your Own” href=”http://l2mastery.com/” target=”_blank”>Foreign Language Mastery</a>, as well as product reviews, corny puns, and interviews with world renowned language learners, linguists, and teachers.
In his comprehensive guide <a title=”Master Japanese: Self-Guided Immersion for the Passionate Language Learner” href=”http://l2mastery.com/language-master-guides/master-japanese-self-guided-immersion-for-the-passionate-language-learner” target=”_blank”>Master Japanese: Self-Guided Immersion for the Passionate Language Learner</a>, he provides all the tips, tools, and strategies adult learners need to acquire the Japanese language quickly, cheaply, enjoyably, and without teachers, classrooms, or textbooks. Oh, and there’s ninjas, too…

From teaching to translating, John Fotheringham has been up and down the entire foreign language continuum (unfortunately, there is no frequent flyer program for language learning).

As both learner and teacher, he has spent the last decade testing first hand what works, and perhaps more importantly, what doesn’t. John shares these results on his blog and podcast Foreign Language Mastery, as well as product reviews, corny puns, and interviews with world renowned language learners, linguists, and teachers.

In his comprehensive guide Master Japanese: Self-Guided Immersion for the Passionate Language Learner, he provides all the tips, tools, and strategies adult learners need to acquire the Japanese language quickly, cheaply, enjoyably, and without teachers, classrooms, or textbooks. Oh, and there’s ninjas, too…

***********************

Enter your email in the top right of the site to subscribe to the Language Hacking League e-mail list for way more tips sent directly to your inbox!

If you enjoyed this post, you will love my TEDx talk! You can get much better details of how I recommend learning a language if you watch it here.

This article was written by

Comments: If you liked this post or have anything to say, please leave a comment! I love reading them :)
Just keep in mind that I’ll delete any rude, trolling, spammy, irrelevant or way off-topic comments. If you have a general language learning question, please ask it in the forums. Otherwise please use the search tool on the right for any other question not related to this post.

———————————–

  • http://twitter.com/TimmyBurns Tim Webster

    This is awesome. I love the way the post was written out. One of my 28-day challenges is to learn an intermediate level of Spanish but I need to be able to specify that more, and create some measurable goal, otherwise the goal will just look like, ‘Learn some Spanish in 28 days’ which is pretty ambiguous!

    Thanks for the motivation and guidance! =)

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      I am glad you enjoyed the article, Tim!  Specificity is indeed a huge component of effective goal making, as is urgency, which is why 30-day (or even better, “later today”) challenges are so powerful. Thank you for your kind feedback.

  • http://profiles.google.com/chrissomerry Christian Meredith

    Via ligilo pri la thai skribsistemo ne funkcias – la ligilo sendas la uzanto al http://www.fluentin3months.com/2k-kanji/www.fluentin3months.com/phonetic-script-can-be-learned-quickly/ – eble vi bezonas “http://” antaŭ la www?

    • http://www.fluentin3months.com/ Benny Lewis

      Dankon! La nuna versio de Firefox forigas la http:// kaj mi ĉiam kopias el ĝi. Sen tio, la ligilo ne bone funkcias, sed mi ŝanĝis gxin ;)

      • http://profiles.google.com/chrissomerry Christian Meredith

        Dankon, ĝi funkcias bonege nun :) (ĝi estas plia interesa artikolo ankaŭ, kaj la sekvanta pri ĝiaj tonoj ;) )

        • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

          I think I need to finally bite the bullet and learn Esperanto!

          • Kieran Maynard

            It’s a juicy, delicious bullet.

  • http://www.RoadToEpic.com Adam Wik

    Excellent article! I did a 1,000 Korean words in 30 days challenge once using a similar method, but dropped the ball a little in figuring out how to measure my success. I could recognize all the words at the end, but had no idea how to quantify how many I could produce.

    The biggest challenge for me was making sure I worked at it every single day. I think as long as you can find ways to keep your momentum up the rest tends to fall into place.

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      Thank you much, Adam. As Peter Drucker famously stated, “What get’s measured, gets managed”. While he was obviously referring to corporate efficiency, the same applies to language learning as you found out in your 30 day Korean vocabulary challenge. That said, quantifying application is always going to be harder than the explicit memory of facts, which is why (sadly) nearly all of traditional academics focus on the latter.

  • http://twitter.com/Landorien Lan’dorien

    I can attest that this is possible, having done it myself.

    I would suggest though that until you have learned the last kanji in RTK1, instead of Anki use the website at http://kanji.koohii.com/ .  There is a very convenient built-in SRS on the site, but more importantly you can see the mnemonic stories that all the other users have made.  This saves a great deal of time and you can often (depending how good your imagination is!) find stories more memorable than ones you might have made yourself.  Of course if you prefer Anki you can also use that and still make use of the stories.

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      Glad to hear you are one of the many learners who have benefited from the RTK system. Every single person I know who has mastered Japanese kanji in a relatively short amount of time has employed the system (or something just like it), while everyone I know who has failed or struggled on for years uses pure rote memory.

      “Reviewing the Kanji” is indeed a great resource. I just wish they had an iPhone or Android app for on-the-go learning (I tend to avoid website based tools as my travels present spotty internet at best).

      Seeing how others make stories is of course very helpful in the beginning (especially for the adult learner whose creativity muscles have atrophied from lack of use), but as Heisig recommends, but I personally found that making my own stories was more powerful as they related directly to my own unique experience and quirks.

      • http://twitter.com/Landorien Lan’dorien

        Definitely a lot to be said for making your own stories.  I might’ve been in too much of a hurry :) well, they did the job, and I very seldom have to think of the stories anymore.  Often enough I don’t even remember them.

        RevTK do have an iPhone app, not sure about Android.

        http://itunes.apple.com/app/remembering-the-kanji/id424471278?mt=8

        • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

          That’s a good point to bring up. The stories are only necessary in the beginning and will slowly fade away when you don’t need them anymore.

          With regard to the app, I mentioned the Remembering the Kanji iOS app in the article above (it is a great addition to the book; highly recommended). But what I was referring to is a potential “Reviewing the Kanji” app based on the content from http://kanji.koohii.com.

  • http://twitter.com/SuperRocketZach Zach Sarette

    Excellent post! This really hits home with me! 

    Especially the making public and taking bets with friends part! 

    When I learned the 2042 Kanji I was rushing to beat all of my friends who had started and stopped at around 500 -700 in RTK1. 

    Remember, you have to keep on reviewing and learn reading through context (the best way to learn by reading). 

    I didn’t make any bets, but I definitely wanted to beat everyone in my Japanese meetup group in Boston. You don’t have to go as fast as I did. I did it in about 45 days. But I reviewed it months and months after in my SRS.

    The more you review, the better. It’s like reviewing a blackjack strategy table. Certain hands won’t come up just by playing. Memorizing a table will prepare you for adjusting your strategy. 

    I made a video of how I did it. I hope you guys can see that you can do it too. Remember I was extremely motivated. You can do it in 3 months if you’re just a bit motivated. 

    http://youtu.be/CEmq901_4p8

    皆さん、頑張れ! 

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      Thank you for sharing your experience with RTK. It is amazing how much social accountability and a little friendly competition can push us to put in the time day in and day out. And I like your blackjack analogy; natural communication is key but it doesn’t mean you can’t speed up your exposure to useful (albeit somewhat less frequent) material.

  • http://twitter.com/criticalowl Jacob Gill

    Sounds like an awesome challenge, and as someone who has been wanting to study Japanese for a while this is getting book marked. I love the S.M.A.R.T. system that you have set up. I just have a few questions about that I would love to have answered.

    1. Is this learning how to pronounce the words, or are just learning meaning?
    2. Is the person learning how to write the words?
    3. After  learning can one actually use the words?

    I guess I should clarify that I’m coming from knowing Chinese as a second language, and while I don’t know entirely how Kanji works for Japanese, it took years of study to be comfortable with using roughly 2,000 chinese characters, and I would love to know what the actually goal of learning 2,000 Kanji in 3 months really is. 

    For the average Chinese student, knowing 2,000 characters (which I can only assume is the same as Kanji) is well on the way to standard fluency with the language, but from an educational point of view, that is carrying the assumption that the student has learned not only how to pronounce the word, but also write it, and use it correctly in the context of a sentence. So while I love the idea of setting goals and speeding up the learning process, I wonder how much is actually learned in 90 days.

    Thanks!
    Jake

    • http://twitter.com/Landorien Lan’dorien

      1 – just meanings, and incomplete at that; it’s just a single keyword.
      2 – yes, the reviews are all done with kanji production, and stroke order is very important.  As well, learning how the kanji are put together from their components, as you do with RTK, ensures that the stroke orders become second nature.
      3 – not really, no. You don’t learn the readings the first time around.

      The point of RTK is to lay the foundation.  Heisig was inspired by the fact that Chinese students beginning Japanese had such an advantage over Western students, and devised this system to get, initially himself, then others, up to that same beginning point.  Since you are already good at Chinese, you might not need this.

      For learning readings I can highly recommend https://www.readthekanji.com/ .  No vested interest in it at all, just a satisfied user.  It’s the best system I’ve found by a considerable margin.

      Slightly tangential to what you’re asking, but a lot of people dislike RTK because you don’t learn readings, or any words, or any shades of meaning beyond the single keyword.  I picture it like this – you have in front of you a large crowd of people, all of whom you are expected to get to know – maybe you’re teaching a class, or some such.  The very first thing you have to do then, is to learn what names go with what faces.  That’s all.  Finding out their personalities, interests, hobbies, that can come later.  Trying to go into too much detail with each one will only confuse you and will take far too long.

      • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

        Thank you for addressing Jacob’s questions, Lan’dorien. I would add the following:

        Trying to learn all the meanings and readings of the kanji from the get go is one of the problems with traditional kanji learning. As your fluency progresses in the language, you will gradually learn the various differences in meaning, and myriad “onyomi” (音読み “readings of Chinese origin) and “kunyomi” (訓読み “readings of Japanese origin) through sufficient exposure. But to make the process more efficient, I highly recommend Heisig’s second book, “Remembering the Kanji 2: A Systematic Guide to Reading the Japanese Characters”. It is not “required reading” like the first volume, but it will make your life a lot easier.

  • http://twitter.com/Landorien Lan’dorien

    I’m in the middle of learning readings now, and I very much agree that in context, remembering them from certain compounds that you know well, is definitely the best approach.  So when I see 規 for example, it’s not just 規 with the reading hovering somewhere around in a cloud of enigma, but “き from 規則, got it”.

  • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

    Context is paramount, and learning the onyomi of kanji in sets of characters with the same phonetic radical definitely is the way to go. But I don’t think doing so at all conflicts with the approach in RTK 1. What I like about learning the meaning and writing first is that it is not limited by your level of fluency in the language. Even if you don’t speak a word of Japanese, you can get started learning the meaning and writing. Then as your fluency expands, you can begin to fill in the various shades of meaning and the different readings that go with them.

  • http://l2mastery.com/ John Fotheringham

    I am also a night owl, and do most of my learning at night. But if I have enough time in the morning, I do think a quick review of the previous night’s material can greatly improve retention.

    I’ve also had pre-bedtime kanji show up in my dreams, even more so when I create truly crazy stories. It’s great; you can literally learn in your sleep.

  • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

    Thank you for your comment, Dckane.

    There is indeed a massive difference between recognition and production, but that is what makes RTK so effective: instead of trying to remember how to write a random pile of strokes from memory (hard) you simply have to bring back the wacky story you created (easy). You can always tell the difference between who learned by rote and repetition and those who learned by imaginative memory and creative association; the latter group never forgets who to write kanji even if it’s been months since they last encountered it.

    Review is of course crucial, and that is what I recommend using Anki and the RTK iOS app for. Trying to review every character every day is obviously not tenable, but SRS lets you focus on only the characters you’re having the most trouble with instead of wasting time with those you’ve already learned. But again, I find that if I create a strong enough story, I don’t need a lot of subsequent reviews to remember the meaning and writing of new characters. Lots of repetition is becomes more necessary when trying to learn by rote (which is why I recommend using SRS in combination with RTK, not as a substitute.)

  • http://www.chloefan.com/ Chloe

    Have you tried Skritter for learning kanji?

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      Skritter can be a good addition to the tools I list above, and they do offer a number of interesting features, but by itself it can lead the learner to fall back on rote memory and I therefore wouldn’t recommend it as a stand alone tool. Incidentally, the Remembering the Kanji iOS app also offers the same kind of on screen writing practice within the app.

  • Victor Berrjod

    I got through the whole book, but then neglected practising them (outside of using them, that is), so I know about 1000, I guess. I recommend this book to everyone who tell me they’d like to learn Japanese. :)

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      Thank you for helping spread the word about RTK, Victor.

      The official list of standard use kanji was indeed expanded in 2010, but the RTK book and iOS app still only goes up to 2042 so I didn’t want to cause confusion. But once you go through a few thousand characters, learning a hundred more is a just drop in the bucket.

  • Robodl95

    I’m not learning Japanese but this is very helpful. I’ve actually never heard of SMART goals before and I really like the idea. 

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      Yes, other than the specific Japanese tools, the methods and psychology discussed work for ALL languages (or any skill based endeavor for that matter).

  • http://www.bzemic.com/impossibleInstinct/ steve ward

    Thanks John for a great post something bothering me oh, my goal’s go like this

    Language
    goal: Conversational
    Japanese 3 months
    Sub-Goal:
    Finish
    a Japanese novel by November 30 (this might be a bad goal?)goal:?Thoughts? 

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      “Finish a Japanese novel by November 30″ is not a bad goal if your goal is improving your Japanese reading and writing skills, but it will do little for your oral fluency, which appears to be your main goal. I would instead suggest making sub goals of “speaking with a native speaker via Skype at least 1 hour a day” or “listen to Japanese during every commute for 30 days”, etc.

      • http://www.bzemic.com/impossibleInstinct/ steve ward

        Thanks Guest and John for the advice and that make more sense john than what i had

  • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

    The phonetic component of Chinese characters is extremely important and they should be learned in a systematic, efficient way just like the meaning and writing of the characters (hence the 2nd volume of RTK). I don’t think it is wasted effort to create semantic stories for purely phonetic elements; the purpose of the stories is to remember the meaning and writing of characters, not to learn the actual etymology of the characters. If you want to learn the readings at the same time, I say go for it, but in my experience, things went far faster breaking up the process into steps so I didn’t get overwhelmed.

  • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

    Khatzumoto is the man! He is one of the language learning rock stars I interviewed for my Master Japanese guide.

  • Marija Josifovic

    this is brilliant! i need to learn hiragana, katakana and 250 kanjis in 2 months (besides learning japanes vocab and grammar) for uni :( i thought it’s IMPOSSIBLE. this gave me some great ideas and definitely motivated me. ok, here we go…. good luck to everyone else too!

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      That’s great to hear, Marija. 頑張ってね!

    • Kieran Maynard

      Hiragana and katakana can be learned in a few hours! Heisig has a book for them, too, but it’s probably not necessary to buy it. With Heisig’s method you can learn 250 kanji in one day (but of course you’re only 1/8 of the way there.)

  • http://www.bzemic.com/impossibleInstinct/ steve ward

    ok i will check that out too

  • http://www.facebook.com/mohamed.a.manseur Mohamed Amine Manseur

    i’ve got about 1000 kanji memorized , but they’re easily going away

    • Kieran Maynard

      Use Anki.

  • http://twitter.com/jessie00x jd

    Great post, thanks for sharing John!

    I don’t fault your method, but I was just thinking, it sounds like a good goal going through the readings/meanings of 2,000+ kanji in a few months, and even perhaps some writing/strokes, but wouldn’t it be so much harder and more time consuming, to learn the compound kanji as well within that time frame? 2,000 kanji can make up 4,000+ words or more! Yet, it is quite essential to do so, since learning each kanji on their own without much context can make them harder to remember.

    Also, I’m interested in how you find the motivation to actually carry on with the plan, and make sure you do something everyday? You’ve described how one could get started, but I find the hardest thing is not drawing up the initial plan, but sticking to it.

    May your Japanese prosper!
    Jess

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      Thank you for your comment, Jess.

      To clarify, the method I recommend above is for learning the MEANING and WRITING of all standard use kanji. Learning the readings (as well as the meaning of kanji compounds) will of course take more time, effort, and exposure, but having the meanings and writings under your belt will give you a huge head start (comparable to native Mandarin speakers who learn Japanese).

      With regard to staying staying the course day in and day out, it is imperative to use social accountability (i.e. sharing your goals with others) and create real consequences for reaching (or not reaching) your goals in a given time frame. To this end, I suggest using sites like Stickk.com or Beeminder.com, and habit formation apps like Habit List, Everest, or Lift.

  • Vamp898

    What do you mean with learning all Kanji?

    I mean, learning the writing and all Readings in 3 Months, thats quite impossible.

    Also you mention WWWJDIC as ultimate Source, i doubt that.

    Every kun-reading is a japanese word itself so if a kanji have 5 kun-reading, every 5 kun-readings are words itself and they sometimes mean very different things.

    WWWJDIC lists the Kanji –> all readings –> all meanings. You dont know which meaning belongs to which reading so this will lead you to a complete mess and misunderstanding of the kanji. You can easily say “excrement office” when you want to say “post office” just because you choose the wrong reading for the Kanji because you dont know which reading means excrement and what post.

    便 with reading ビン = mail/post/letter
    便 with reading ベン = excrement/stool

    you better know the right meaning ;)

    Also the 2040 kun-readings in the 常用漢字 are normally written with okurigana so they are not the Kanji itself, they are Kanji + Hiragana. Every kun-reading normally have it own okurigana.

    So you have to learn

    - 2136 Kanji with 2354 readings
    - 2040 Kanji(Okurigana) + which reading is for which Kanji(Okurigana) combination

    あかり and あかす are both readings of 明 but dont mean the same at all.

    One is Light/bright and the other is “spend the night together”

    You cant learn all 4394 readings with all Kanji/Kanji(Okurigana) in 3 Months.

    And if you dont learn them that way, its completely useless to learn them at all.

    Sure if you have fun learning it, its still fun. But it wont really help you with japanese. If you learn the Kanji because you want to learn Japanese, there is only one way!

    If you want to learn all 常用漢字 in one year (which is really painfull), then you have to learn about 42 Kanji per Week (with all readings!) and this is quite heavy.

    No way ever you can correct learn them in 3 Months. Tell whatever you want but all the afford will be for nothing in the end.

    • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

      Learning the readings of kanji is of course an essential component of learning kanji, but order of operations is important. Trying to learn the readings AND meanings at the same time (the painful, inefficient, and ineffective approach found in most traditional Japanese language classes and textbooks) is simply overwhelming for most people, and leads many to simply give up. The importance I place on fun is not just to make the process more enjoyable; it is also a matter of results. As Khatzumoto says, “Fun gets done!” Or as Tim Ferriss says, “The imperfect approach that you stick with is far better than the perfect approach you quit.”

      Another major advantage of learning meanings first is that it doesn’t depend on one’s level in Japanese.You can learn meanings even if you are completely new to Japanese. Or to look at it another way, consider the case of native Mandarin speakers learning Japanese: they tend to pick up the language far quicker than Western learners because they already know the meaning and writing of nearly all kanji (except those that are written slightly differently or have subtle differences in meaning).

      Your approach may work for some (nobody that I’ve ever met), but for the vast majority of adult learners, it is far more effective, efficient, and enjoyable to learn the meanings first, and then learn each character’s on-yomi, kun-yomi, and okurigana. Moreover, once you recognize all standard use kanji, it is far easier to spot onyomi patterns (e.g. I know that most kanji with radical X are pronounced Y or Z).

      • Vamp898

        > is simply overwhelming for most people, and leads many to simply give up.

        It is how it is. They want to learn a language or? You dont learn the language because you want to have fun, you learn it because you want to be able to understand and use it.

        If i want fun i turn on my playstation, not learn the language with the most painfull writing system in world.

        Normally you learn japanese because you want to use it. You have to learn it the hard way if you want to use it in Japan as your everyday language.

        Most companies want the JLPT N1 if you apply for a job and at latest then you need to be able to handle the Kanji perfect.

        Less than 50% of the people who apply the JLPT N1 get the certificate. Thats quite a horrible success rate and the reason is that people try to learn it the “easy” way instead of the real way.

        > Your approach may work for some (nobody that I’ve ever met)

        Go to japan and search for someone who is not japanese and understands perfectly japanese texts. There you go. They either learned a horrible long time (inefficient) or learned the right way.

        > it is far more effective, efficient, and enjoyable to learn the meanings first

        But that doesnt help you anything with the Japanese language and that is the only sense of Kanji as they are the largest writing system in Japan.

        Also it often dont works as the japanese tends to give Kanji sometimes complete different meanings (best examples i opsted above). So you have to remember that the Kanji for excrement is the same kanji as for mail/post. That doesnt give any sense if you dont know the readings and the usage of them. Kanji only makes sense if you know the readings and the usage of the readings in combination with the meaning. To learn all together is more usefull than to learn only one part. Reading, meaning and usage is one unit. One Kanji.

        Kanji never have been designed to be fun. If someone doesnt have the time/motiviation to learn it the painfull way, he will never be able to write real texts with Kanji.

        Maybe we differ in our meaning of “effective” and maybe we even have a huge difference in thinking about “why learn kanji”. Your way is easier, but not more effective. Until you can handle the Kanji perfect you need much more time than with the “painfull” way. You have just more fun and you have faster results, but you cannot use those results.

        You can only use Kanji if you have them completely, not just partwise. To have them completely takes more time with your way than with the real way.

        So i call this less effectiv. More easie but less effective.

        • david flores

          Hey Vamp, just a question. I want to learn them the right way as you say, so what would you recommend I do? Is there a book/resource I can use to learn them? Should I learn them based on the way the Japanese learn them? I would really like to know cuz there is just so many books/resources and ways they say to learn them, and I dont know where to start. Thanks

        • Kieran Maynard

          Kanji don’t have meanings. They are a greatly elaborated syllabary. There is no “kanji for post” or “kanji for excrement.” As for that example, べん「便」is a morpheme that means “easy” and びん「便」means “message.” The first reading is vastly more common (at least 80-20, probably 90-10).

          • Vamp898

            Kanji have meaning. Dont know which dumbass told you something different, even 1-grade shool children learn that.

            The On-Readings of the Kanji are only syllabary, every kun-reading is a full japanese word like in 赤 reading “aka” meaning “red” or 朝 reading “asa” meaning morning.

            There are 4 things important about a Kanji

            - Stroke Order
            - Meaning
            - On Reading
            - Kun Reading

            The Meaning is very important because the Meaning tells you in which context you use the on-reading.

            If you would have learned Kanji the correct way, you would know that.

            So there is a Kanji meaning “Post” and its on-reading is used in context with post-related stuff.

      • Kieran Maynard

        I disagree about learning readings. Japanese people don’t think about kanji as having “readings.” They say, “The しょう in 将来,” or “めいじ, written ‘明かして治む’.” They are reading their native language, so they know most of the words when they learn in school. They don’t think, “The kanji 明 has two kunyomi and two onyomi,” they think “It’s 明治の「明」.” If you memorize readings and try to figure out which one to use, you will make many mistakes. If you learn the words and the written form in kanji of those words, you can’t read 郵便局 as ゆうべんきょく because that just isn’t a word!

    • Kieran Maynard

      Don’t learn the readings of kanji. Learn Japanese, which happens to be written with lots of kanji. Learn Heisig’s keywords, which are like a scaffolding that will gradually disappear as you learn real words in context. You can’t say “excrement office” because that’s not a word in Japanese. (The phrase would be “くそ事務所!” if you’re curious. :) And ゆうべんきょく sounds like “The Eloquency Department” [雄弁局] = awesome. I digress…)

      Learning all the keywords in Heisig 1 in two weeks is possible. (I did it. I even did Heisig 3 in a week, which was fun but a waste of time.) Depends on how many kanji you learn a day! Just get through Heisig and start real Japanese!

      • Vamp898

        > Don’t learn the readings of kanji. Learn Japanese, which happens to be written with lots of kanji.

        Than you can only read exactly those words and not other words using the same Kanjis as they might use different readings (keyword Ateji).

        Also you cant pass JLPT without that and without JLPT you have nothing that proofs you are able of Japanese.

        Sure Heisig is a easy way to learn, but you wont pass JLPT nor be able to read real Japanese.

        If that would be real Japanese, the japanese would learn it like that. But they dont as this is just stupid. Heisigs way is learning Vocabulary using Kanji, not learning Kanji.

        Thats something completely differnet and you _have_ to learn Kanji if you want be able to read Japanese.

        • Kieran Maynard

          First, let me say I didn’t learn Japanese to pass the JLPT. Second, you can pass the JLPT simply by being really good at Japanese.

          By learning to read words, you can read exactly those words, because that’s the point. You can then guess the readings of new words based on the ones you know (but will still need to look them up to confirm).

          No, you cannot pass the JLPT 1 after doing Heisig. That’s like saying, “Sure, you can hit a golf ball, but you still can’t beat Tiger Woods.” All in good time.

          Heisig’s method doesn’t teach vocabulary. It teaches you to associate kanji with keywords. Heisig prepares you to learn vocabulary.

          I learned all the joyo kanji by memorizing words. Memorizing readings will cause you to produce words that don’t exist by reading them wrong. I’m not defending Heisig’s method. I’m saying, “Hey, I can read Murakami novels and stuff in Japanese. This is how I got there.”

          • Vamp898

            > First, let me say I didn’t learn Japanese to pass the JLPT.

            Then its a waste of time. The JLPT is the only thing that certificates that you are able to speak japanese.

            Nobody learns 27 hours a week Japanese for 18 Months just for fun. Either you learn it complete and can speak it, or you waste your time.

            > I learned all the joyo kanji by memorizing words. Memorizing readings will cause you to produce words that don’t exist by reading them wrong.

            It also gives you the possibility to read words that you dont know. The chance to read a unkown word wrong is very low, on the other hand a very very lot of Japanese words dont use the reading.

            Let us take 今日 which reads きょう or the word 月 which reads つき

            If you only know the readings きょう and つき you will be never able to know that 今月 reads こんげつ

            The JLPT-N1 isnt like beating Tiger Woods, the JLPT-N1 is “fluent Japanese in theory” (more like “the basics” to be able to get fluent in japanese) which is the absolute minimum to live in Japan.

            Beating Tiger Woods its far from that, its more like playing golf without loosing against everyone in the amateuer leauge

            If you dont intend to live in Japan the afford to learn Japanese correct and complete is an absolute waste of time as you will never be able to do so without using it every day.

            So there are 2 very important rules

            1. Learn Japanese _only_ if you intend to live in Japan or because you want/need it for your job

            2. Do the JLPT

            Try to play a real Visual Novell like “リトルバスターズ” which is for teenagers and so quite easy to understand and see how you will fail.

            Maybe it is possible to learn all 常用漢字 just by learning vocabulary using it, but thats an very ineffective way which tends to a lot of errors and mistakes. Defenetly nothing you want if you want to learn Japanese for real.

            If you just dont intend to get your Japanese be good enough to live in Japan and you’re fine with reading some easy books where you have tons of time to check every word, than that shouldnt be the advice to give to others.

            That maybe sounds harsh but learning Japanese is not designed to be fun. Its designed to be a spoken language and learning that is “work”, not “fun”. Fun is just what you do with your knowledge rather than getting the knowledge itself.

          • Kieran Maynard

            I couldn’t agree less. Learning is not about tests. Even if you have no intention to live in Japan, learning Japanese is a valuable experience and the language opens doors for opportunities all over the world. For example, I’m studying Chinese literature in Shanghai, but because I speak Japanese I can converse with the visiting professors from Japan, take classes in Japanese in the Japanese department, make Japanese friends, watch Japanese movies without subtitles, and read Murakami Haruki’s novels in the original. I’ve never taken the JLPT, but have never once felt like I wasted my time. Everyone’s path is different. There are no “rules.” As Rip Slyme says, “Do what you like!”

          • http://www.fluentin3months.com/ Benny Lewis

            What a depressing thought – that you actually believe someone’s level and hard work is worthless without passing some random exam. You should immediately dismiss all natives too then if you care to be consistent.

            “That maybe sounds harsh but learning Japanese is not designed to be fun.”
            Japanese IS NOT DESIGNED period, and “learning Japanese” being designed or not makes no sense whatsoever.

            I only have to wonder if your comment is some caricature or intentionally taking the piss when you claim that learning a language is only worthwhile if you intend to live in the country or need it for a job. What narrow minded tripe! What about if you are in love with someone? Or you are passionate about the culture but don’t plan to move there, and want to consume it from afar? Or if there is a strong community where you live or if your family is Japanese?

            Yours is the most ridiculous comment I’ve seen on this site in a while, and that really says something considering the amount I get.

          • Vamp898

            > Or you are passionate about the culture but don’t plan to move there, and want to consume it from afar?

            That is the reason why 99% of people learn Japanese and until now they either gave up or went to japan. Mysterious isnt it?

            Japanese is not just any language, its a language you _have_ to use every day of your life a very lot to get fluent in it and to _stay_ fluent.

            I doubt that 75% of your day you speak Japanese (especially not with native Japanese speakers).

            > Or if there is a strong community where you live or if your family is Japanese?

            If your famaly is japanese i doubt they would say “Use Heisig” :D its for a good reason that the Japanese learn Kanji and Vocabulary separated in shool and that they learn all the readings.

            Sure everyone can learn Japanese if he wants, but than stop searching for fucking shortcuts. A Language is not about searching for shortcuts.

            THERE ARE NO SHORTCUTS WHEN LEARNING A LANGUAGE

            and heisig _is_ designed to be a shortcut which is stupid as fuck

            If you want to learn Japanese, learn it correct or you will _never_ be able to use it correct.

            If you will never be able to use it correct, its a complete waste of time.

            As i said, learning Japanese takes a lot of time, when learning Kanji you learn

            - 7 Kanji per Weekdays (3 hours long)

            - 14 Kanji per Weekenddays (6 hours long)

            That makes 63 Kanji a Week

            When learning Vocabulary you learn

            - 25 Vocabulary per Weekdays (3 hours long)

            - 50 Vocabulary per Weekenddays (6 hours long)

            That makes 225 Vocabulary a day

            Thats really pain in the ass and you have to do that for 18 Months until you have the ability to pass JLPT-N1!

            For the most people with a Job that means that there complete free time is taken for learning Japanese and that for 18 Months!.

            After that you are _forced_ to use all your free-time to use your Japanese to dont loose it is you just learned it.

            Do you really want to “train” Japanese the rest of your life in all your free time? No! Are you able to speak correct and complete Japanese if you dont? No!

            So there is only 1 Solution –> Move to the Country or accept the downsides.

            If the downside isnt a problem for you, then you’re fine, but i want free-time in my life

          • http://www.fluentin3months.com/ Benny Lewis

            99%? As I said, I find this entire tangent to be ridiculous. Pulling figures out of your ass and caps-locking strawman arguments doesn’t help. Many English mistakes don’t help either.

            Focusing only on shortcuts as ways of avoiding work are indeed for the lazy and will ultimately lead to failure. Shortcuts as a way to *improve* your strategy so that you learn more efficiently is for smarter learners, and that includes ways to spend less than 3 hours to learn 7 Kanji. What a preposterous estimation!

          • Vamp898

            Dont forget repeating.

            not 3 hours for 7 Kanji, 3 hours for 7 Kanji _every day_

            As said, 63 Kanji a week with _all_ readings and you have to be able to read them like you can read our alphabet

            Shortcuts == leave something out

            _always_

            so Shortcut is not for the smart guys, its _only_ for the lazy guys and limited to those.

            As already said, its not for no reason that the Japanese learn it the same way.

  • david flores

    Thanks Vamp! I got the book you were talking about and it is really good, especially the compund thing where it only uses kanji learned beforehand for the current kanji you are learning for compound examples.

    • Vamp898

      I know. I personally dont learn all conpunds as im going to learn the JLPT vocabulary after the book (using Kanji for sure) so i will learn the compounds afterwards. That way i can learn 7 Kanji per day with all readings. If you learn them _with_ the compounds (highly recommend for the first Kanjis) i recommend 4 Kanji per day.

      On weekends you can double the amount of Kanji. I learn 7 Kanji from Mo-Fr (7 per day) and on Sat/Sun i learn 14 per Day.

      With Compounds its about 4 per Day in week, 5 on friday, 11 on saturday and 10 on sunday. That way you have all the Kanji in one year with all readings!

  • Kieran Maynard

    Why be a naysayer?

    How do you count your grammatical phrases…? That sounds like a waste of time.

    “The Tale of Genji” is 1000 years old. I can’t even understand Chaucer.

  • Kieran Maynard

    The phonetic components are not particularly helpful in guessing pronunciation, so I’d go with stories.

  • http://l2mastery.com John Fotheringham

    Some great apps and sites have come along (or at least come to my attention) since I wrote the article. Here are a few updated recommendations: 1) Instead of WWWJDIC, I recommend using Tangorin (単語林), available free online at http://tangorin.com. It is well designed and has an awesome Anki export option. 2) For iOS, I highly recommend the Midori dictionary available in the App Store for $9.99. Not cheap, but it is well worth the price. In addition to quickly constraining the search results to the general dictionary, Japanese names, or example sentences, they also have a native, Japanese-specific handwriting input option. Prior to this, I suggested the stop-gap solution of using the built-in handwriting input for Traditional Chinese on iOS devices, but this doesn’t work for characters that are written differently in Chinese and Japanese. 3) The best Japanese dictionary for Android still appears to be the WWWJDIC app. It’s not perfect but it has a lot of features and allows handwriting input. I don’t have an Android phone, however, and can’t currently test new options. Any Android users out there who’ve found a better option?